Identifying Underperforming Buildings: Strategies to Target Energy Efficiency Improvements

Commercial properties often hide inefficiencies that can lead to unnecessary energy waste and inflated operating costs. Detailed benchmarking data turns raw energy usage into actionable insights, enabling building operators to pinpoint underperforming systems and prioritize upgrades that improve asset management and yield significant cost savings. This article explains how to use key performance indicators and data analysis techniques to identify buildings that perform below par and outlines strategies for targeting energy efficiency improvements that boost overall performance.

The Strategic Role of Benchmarking in Commercial Building Management

Benchmarking transforms raw energy consumption data into standardized performance metrics, offering a clear view of how a building performs relative to its peers. This systematic measurement enables building operators to identify inefficiencies that might not be apparent from routine maintenance checks. Data-driven insights from benchmarking not only support targeted energy conservation measures (ECMs) but also form the foundation for proactive asset management decisions that reduce energy use and lower operating costs.

Why Focus on Underperforming Buildings?

Underperforming buildings are those that consume significantly more energy than similar properties. Even when systems are technically operational, they may be inefficient due to outdated technologies, improper calibration, or suboptimal operating practices. Identifying these buildings allows property managers to target improvements where they will have the highest impact. Addressing inefficiencies in energy-intensive systems often leads to immediate reductions in utility costs and contributes to long-term asset value enhancement.

Understanding Benchmarking Data

Key Performance Indicators for Commercial Buildings

Energy Use Intensity (EUI)

Energy Use Intensity (EUI) is the most widely used metric for comparing energy performance. Expressed as energy consumed per square foot, EUI offers a standardized way to assess whether a building is using more energy than expected. High EUI values can signal problems such as inefficient HVAC systems, outdated lighting, or poor insulation. Monitoring EUI over time provides property managers with a clear picture of a building’s operational performance and highlights areas for further investigation.

Comparative Analysis Techniques

Benchmarking data is most valuable when it allows for comparison across similar buildings. By comparing a building’s energy use with that of its peers, operators can establish a baseline of performance. Statistical methods, such as calculating averages or standard deviations, help identify outliers—buildings that deviate significantly from the norm. This comparative analysis not only highlights underperforming assets but also provides context for setting realistic energy efficiency goals.

Interpreting Benchmarking Data to Identify Underperformance

Recognizing Data Outliers

A fundamental step in identifying underperformance is recognizing when a building’s metrics fall outside of typical ranges. Outlier analysis, using tools such as trend lines and statistical thresholds, can pinpoint buildings that consume far more energy per square foot than their peers. Operators can use this information to investigate further—determining whether high energy use is due to system inefficiencies, maintenance issues, or other operational factors.

Analyzing Operational Factors

Energy consumption in a commercial building is affected by many variables, including HVAC settings, lighting schedules, occupancy patterns, and equipment efficiency. Detailed analysis of benchmarking data, alongside operational records, can reveal mismatches between expected and actual performance. For example, if a building consistently shows high energy use during off-peak hours, it may indicate that systems are running unnecessarily. Such insights provide a roadmap for adjustments that can significantly improve efficiency.

Strategies to Target Energy Efficiency Improvements

Conducting Detailed Energy Audits

Prioritizing Buildings for Audits

Benchmarking data can be used to rank buildings within a portfolio, allowing property managers to prioritize which properties require a thorough energy audit. By focusing on buildings that exhibit high Energy Use Intensity (EUI) or low performance scores, managers can target those assets that stand to benefit the most from an energy audit. Establishing clear criteria for selecting buildings based on performance metrics ensures that resources are allocated effectively.

Using Audit Findings to Drive Improvements

Once a building is flagged as underperforming, a comprehensive energy audit can identify specific systems and components responsible for high energy use. The audit will typically reveal areas where simple adjustments—such as recalibrating HVAC systems or upgrading lighting controls—can lead to immediate cost savings. Detailed audit reports serve as blueprints for implementing targeted Energy Conservation Measures (ECMs) that improve overall building performance and reduce costs.

Implementing Retrofit and Upgrade Measures

Evaluating Cost-Effective Upgrades

Benchmarking data provides a clear picture of which systems consume the most energy and where upgrades are most needed. For instance, if data analysis shows that lighting systems are consuming excessive energy compared to industry benchmarks, a retrofit to LED lighting may yield substantial cost savings. Evaluating the cost-effectiveness of such upgrades is critical; property managers should use ROI calculations to compare the upfront costs with the expected long-term savings. This ensures that capital investments are made where they can deliver the highest returns.

Case Studies and Best Practices

Real-world examples help illustrate the benefits of targeted upgrades. Case studies may demonstrate how retro-commissioning projects in underperforming buildings led to marked improvements in energy performance and significant cost reductions. Best practices from these projects can be shared across a portfolio, enabling property managers to replicate successful strategies. Highlighting tangible results, such as improvements in ENERGY STAR®

Scores or reductions in EUI, reinforces the value of a data-driven approach to energy efficiency.

Continuous Monitoring and Verification

The Importance of Ongoing Performance Tracking

Continuous monitoring is essential to ensure that energy efficiency improvements are not only achieved, but also sustained over time. Benchmarking data should be reviewed regularly to verify that implemented measures continue to deliver savings. Without ongoing tracking, energy consumption may gradually return to previous levels—a phenomenon known as “snapback.”

Preventing Snapback in Energy Savings

Effective monitoring allows building operators to detect when energy usage begins to increase after improvements. By setting up automated alerts and conducting regular performance reviews, property managers can quickly address any deviations from expected savings. Implementing preventive measures, such as periodic recalibration of equipment and maintenance of retro-commissioned systems, helps ensure that energy savings are maintained in the long run.

Tools for Data Verification

Numerous tools are available to verify the accuracy of benchmarking data. Automated data collection systems, real-time dashboards, and custom reporting software all play a role in ensuring that energy performance is tracked accurately. These tools provide property managers with the confidence that their energy conservation measures are effective and that the building continues to operate efficiently.

The Benefits of Targeting Underperforming Buildings

Financial Benefits and ROI

Lower Operating Costs

Identifying and upgrading underperforming buildings can lead to substantial reductions in operating expenses. When inefficiencies are corrected—through retro-commissioning, equipment upgrades, or improved operational practices—energy consumption decreases, resulting in lower utility bills. The immediate financial savings, combined with the long-term benefits of reduced maintenance and extended equipment life, create a compelling case for investing in energy efficiency.

Enhanced Capital Investment Decisions

Benchmarking data provides property managers with a clear basis for prioritizing capital investments. By focusing on buildings that perform poorly relative to their peers, building  operators can direct resources to areas where the potential for energy savings is greatest. Detailed ROI analyses help ensure that every dollar invested in energy conservation measures yields measurable returns, boosting overall asset value and operational efficiency.

Keywords: ROI, lower operating costs, capital investments, energy savings, benchmarking, Benchmark Your Building.

Enhanced Operational Efficiency

Improved Equipment Performance and Longevity

Targeted upgrades and routine maintenance, guided by benchmarking insights, can extend the life of critical building systems. When equipment operates efficiently, maintenance costs decrease, and the need for premature replacement is minimized. This not only lowers operating expenses but also ensures that building assets continue to perform at optimal levels, contributing to overall operational excellence.

Strengthened Asset Management

A data-driven approach to asset management enables property managers to keep a close eye on energy performance trends over time. By identifying underperforming buildings and tracking improvements after ECM implementation, managers can better plan for future upgrades and manage their portfolios more effectively. This proactive management strategy leads to increased asset longevity and improved market competitiveness.

Market Competitiveness and Sustainability

Increased Property Value and Tenant Appeal

Energy-efficient buildings are more attractive to tenants and investors alike. When benchmarking data reveals a building’s superior performance, it not only reduces operating expenses but also enhances the property’s marketability. Higher energy efficiency is often associated with lower utility bills and a smaller environmental footprint—factors that can lead to higher rental premiums and improved occupancy rates. Additionally, transparency in energy performance can become a significant selling point, differentiating a property in the market.

Supporting Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR)

Transparency in energy performance reinforces a building owner’s commitment to sustainability and corporate social responsibility. By benchmarking and publicly reporting energy use, property managers demonstrate accountability and foster trust with tenants, investors, and the community. This commitment to sustainability not only contributes to environmental protection but also enhances the property’s reputation, leading to increased market value and a competitive edge.

Analyzing KPI

The process of identifying underperforming buildings through benchmarking is a critical step toward optimizing energy efficiency in commercial properties. By carefully analyzing key performance indicators such as Energy Use Intensity (EUI) and comparing energy consumption across similar buildings, property managers can identify inefficiencies that might otherwise remain hidden. Targeted energy audits and retro-commissioning projects, guided by these data-driven insights, lead to significant reductions in energy use, lower operating costs, and improved asset management.

The benefits extend beyond immediate financial savings. Enhanced operational efficiency, longer equipment life cycles, and improved market competitiveness all contribute to a robust, sustainable property portfolio. Furthermore, continuous monitoring and regular performance verification ensure that energy savings are sustained over time, preventing the potential for snapback and supporting long-term regulatory compliance.

Adopting a data-driven approach to energy management empowers property managers to make informed decisions that drive operational excellence. The strategic benefits—ranging from enhanced asset management and increased ROI to higher property values and stronger sustainability credentials—underline the transformative impact of benchmarking on commercial building performance.

Every building has the potential to operate more efficiently. By leveraging comprehensive benchmarking data and targeted energy conservation measures, property managers can unlock significant cost savings and improve overall performance. The insights provided through this process are crucial for staying ahead of maintenance issues, optimizing capital investments, and ensuring that your building remains a competitive, sustainable asset.

The value of a proactive, data-driven energy management strategy cannot be overstated. With continuous monitoring, predictive maintenance, and tailored energy solutions, commercial properties can achieve measurable improvements that not only reduce operating costs but also enhance asset value and support long-term sustainability goals. The comprehensive insights gained from benchmarking empower property managers to Benchmark Your Building effectively, driving both immediate and lasting benefits.

Benchmark Your Building

Commercial property managers seeking to harness the full potential of energy benchmarking are encouraged to take action now. Gain access to actionable insights that drive significant energy savings, optimize asset management, and support long-term operational excellence.

Partner with Benchmarking Buildings to transform raw utility data into strategic, actionable insights. Unlock measurable cost savings, enhance operational efficiency, and increase the value of your commercial portfolio through advanced, data-driven energy management. Take the decisive step to Benchmark Your Building and secure a sustainable, efficient future for your assets.

Energy benchmarking is more than a measurement exercise—it is a powerful tool that drives continuous improvement, supports strategic investment, and builds a sustainable foundation for future success. By identifying underperforming buildings and targeting inefficiencies, property managers can reduce energy consumption and operating costs, while enhancing the overall performance and marketability of their assets. The comprehensive, data-driven approach offered by Benchmarking Buildings ensures that every decision is informed by reliable, actionable insights, empowering you to Benchmark Your Building and achieve operational excellence.

By integrating these strategies into your asset management plan, you not only improve the immediate energy performance of your building but also lay the groundwork for long-term success. The journey toward sustainable energy efficiency begins with accurate data and ends with measurable improvements in performance, cost savings, and market competitiveness. Embrace the opportunity to optimize your energy management strategy with a mission-driven approach that delivers both financial and environmental benefits.

For property managers ready to unlock the full potential of their commercial buildings, the time to act is now. Partner with Benchmarking Buildings, and let our expertise and comprehensive services guide you toward a future of enhanced efficiency, reduced costs, and long-term asset value.